The Case of Pat O’Byrne

The thing is, I’ve been reading until tears filled my eyes, and I’ve been clicking “Likes” and commenting as if my life depended on it.  Then I realized I’ve left you guys off the hook just too long.  So, I decided it was time to throw in another story.  But it won’t hurt much: it’s very short.  And, in my opinion, which counts for nothing for you as readers, but is the only thing that matters for me as author, this piece is entertaining.  Really… and don’t look at me like that!

The Case of Pat O’Byrne      [ short story – Sha’Tara]

[Before the magistrate of the county court on a beautiful Monday morning]

“Mr. O’Byrne, you were arrested Saturday night for drunk and disorderly conduct — how do you plead?”

“M’Lord, with all due respect, I plead not guilty, sir.”

“Very well.  What have you to say in your defense before this court?”

“Yore ‘onor, I ‘ave never been drunk in me entire life, God’s truth.  Yes, I admit that at times, I’ve left the neighbourhood pub feeling quite light.  I’ve had times when it seemed to me the whole world was one happy place, full of good things and laughter.  Times when I felt as if I could really be one with it all; when the stars moved in the skies, m’lord, and when the moon seemed brighter for the lightness of it all.

Then I’ve had those rare moments when, in the middle of this great and wonderful feeling, all things around me seemed to want to come to me and talk to me.  And that, m’lord, is what happened on the night in question.  The sidewalk, that lowly piece of cement that people trample under foot day after day, that never complains nor shirks its duty, well sir, it rose up to me to talk and got a bit too close, hitting me in the face.  Everything would have been fine had not officer Maloney happened by, arresting me for drunk and disorderly conduct… Truly, m’lord, I was havin’ meself a deeply moving spiritual experience…”

“Are you quite finished, Mr.. O’Byrne?”

“Finished, m’lord?  How can such a wonderful story every be finished?  One may as well ask God if he is finished, then!”

“Enough of this.  I fine the defendant one hundred Euro plus costs.  This case is closed.”


“What, what is it now, officer Maloney?  You got your conviction, didn’t you?”

“Well m’lord, what’s to be done about the sidewalk, then?”

“What are you on about, Maloney?” (with a definite air of deep frustration, being already late for his noon meal with judge Fergus…)

“Well m’lord, that bit o’ sidewalk that up and hit O’Byrne in the face, it’d still be standin’ up, an’ no one to put it back down to be sure.


12 thoughts on “The Case of Pat O’Byrne

      1. Woebegone but Hopeful

        A brilliant comic. His fund of religious jokes were incredible; he had a large number of fans in catholic priests and nuns who as one commentator said ‘got the joke, behind the joke’


  1. Lisa R. Palmer

    Beautiful!! Well done! It isn’t easy to get truth and entertainment in the same sentence (so to speak), but here you have accomplished it with ease! Thanks for the laughter. And the reminder… 🙂


  2. We come from dreams ~

    Well noo, it’s be seemin to me that His Worship was not at all in the dispensin o’ Justice nor wi’ the keepin o’ the Law. For how could any man wi’ a lick o’ sense see where this ommadawn o’ a Judge give even a wee bit o’ inquiry into the condition o’ the sidewalk? An’ ne’er mind O’Byrne declaimin’ Wisdom worthy o’ Bless’d Patrick his self!

    I thought I was gonna pee myself reading this! FUNNY!


    1. Sha'Tara Post author

      Glad you liked it. And I like your comment’s particular English too. (“An’ ne’er mind O’Byrne declaimin’ Wisdom worthy o’ Bless’d Patrick his self!”)


  3. Regis Auffray

    Interesting story… …thank you for sharing.

    “What are you on about, Maloney?” (with a definite air of deep frustration, bring already late for his noon meal with judge


    You must have meant to write “being” I think.




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.