What’s the good of Freedom to the Ignorant?

                     [thoughts from   ~burning woman~   ]

“What’s the good of freedom to the ignorant?” (Ursula K. LeGuin, “Powers”)

A critical question that should be endlessly considered by those who claim to live in freedom; who claim to live within democracies.  Are these people intelligently educated, and are they, in fact, free?  To the intelligently educated, the word “freedom” conveys an endless number of meanings, and shades of meaning, constantly being internally debated.

But what does it mean to an ignorant lout?  A redneck?  A “fool” who lives at the beck and call of guts and brawn?  To the consummate shopper?  To the assembly line worker mind-numbed and beaten by endless, meaningless labour? To the denizen of the computerized cube farm? 

Raised in “relative poverty” (Canadian style, meaning we almost always had enough to eat, and enough clothing and housing to survive the harsh elements of a northern clime – nobody froze to death) I remember only too well having to interact with braggart, illiterate ignorance in grade school.  Later, standing alongside never stopping feed belts in canneries, numbed by the repetitiveness and clanking, hissing noise, checking, adjusting, clearing, stacking… I remember my quickly fading choices.  Was this back-breaking, brain-numbing work going to be my life?

To the ignorant, such situations call for camaraderie: misery loves company, and there was a lot of company; too much company.  These are also great opportunities for ass-kissers and bullies to rise quickly to their own levels of incompetence, loved by higher levels of managers because they consider this loyalty to the company, hence to themselves.  These are the people who snitch and prevent rebellions and talk of unionization, or who management encourages in seditious talk against unions to other employees in hopes of de-certification.  

And so, the ignorant are the great base, the pedestal upon which the masters wine and dine themselves, taking, taking and taking, never having to give any account to anyone because they have their ignorant base to walk over; to dance on. 

In America, the world just witnessed the “election” of a thorough boor, elected and to this moment, supported, by the ignorant masses who fear freedom above anything else, because they know that freedom entails responsibility and responsibility demands the kind of commitment they aren’t willing to put their minds into.  The chains worn by the consumer society do not seem so onerous to bear.

“The wall of forgetting was down.  I was able to think, to speak, to remember.  I was free.  Freedom was unspeakable anguish.” (Ursula K. LeGuin, “Powers”)

In such a morally depraved civilization as this, if “it” is making you feel safe, comfortable, happy, “it” isn’t freedom.  If it is making you rich, with power over others, “it” isn’t freedom.  If if demands that you arm yourselves to the teeth to go and oppress and exploit others in their own countries, to force them to your ways and to take their resources and labour, “it” certainly isn’t freedom.  Conversely, if “it” is dispossessing you; pushing you into deeper debt; into poverty; unto the street to survive by begging or crime, then obviously “it” isn’t freedom. 

Freedom neither gives, nor requires, any of those things.  Freedom can only be given, and shared, freely between willing participants.  This is what the promoters of “freedom and democracy” western style fear anyone learning about. 

To forestall such a thing becoming too common knowledge they invented the now practically global public school system, unofficially known as Official Brainwashing.  At the end of twelve years, give or take, of this waste of youthful years ooze the drones: workers, believers, consumers, hoarders, spectators, whiners, bitchers, complainers, addicts, gamblers, inmates and voters: the entitled to freedom, western style. 

For those who continue seeking after greater official ignorance comes Academic Higher Ignorance.  At the end of that, degrees indicating successful completion of various courses in Official Master Ignorance are handed out.  Having proved themselves adept at rising to their own level of State Approve Ignorance,  these may then be able to go into various channels of rip-off industry, including banking, politics, drugs, medical business, law, corporate engineering, technology and scientific research and through it all, the military, or Official Murder Industry.  Less prevalent today, but always eager to make a sudden come-back is Religion.  It too demands its slate of Officially Mandated leadership in Statutory Ignorance. 

To ensure only a minimal number ever wake up long enough to realize the massive scam they’ve been led into,  the System saddles their Worthy Ignorant with tens of thousands of dollars’ worth of “student debt”, another euphemism for the slave collar. 

You can’t be rebellious when you need a position to repay your debts, buy a house, and try to match the lifestyle of other Officially Ignorant in your line of pretend expertise.  And if you are not rebelling, you are acquiescing, and if you are acquiescing, you are supporting, and if you are supporting, you are a slave along with the others in your slave quarters.  And your greatest curse is that a part of you is always aware of this fact; a fact that can only be borne by an endless stream of distractions.  Enter the entertainment, news and social Media, organized Sports and spectator politics.  And war.  Ultimately, was is the greatest distraction of them all.  That’s why it’s unofficial title is The Endless War.

Freedom?  Of course I’m free.  I’m free to be an ignorant slave.  No anguish; no moral issues; no agonizing conundrums; no worries.  The “House” will take care of us and all our needs, for the “House” owns us all, amen!  

17 thoughts on “What’s the good of Freedom to the Ignorant?

  1. gserpent

    Great post. I love it! You hit the nail right on the head. The masses are scared of freedom. It’s to much responsibility. They want the government or the imaginary guy in the clouds to think for them. That way they don’t have to take responsibility for themselves. People think they are free. See how far you can get without money. Better yet, disappear without telling anyone and see how long you remain invisible. They don’t like not knowing where there slaves are. You won’t be invisible for long. Again, great post.

    1. Sha'Tara Post author

      Thank you; I really appreciate your comment. Sometimes I think I should ease off on “telling it as I see” but then, somewhat like yourself, how can we keep what we see; what we know, just to ourselves? So, some may not like what they read, but they should ask themselves, ‘why does this upset me, if it is just a meaningless rant?’ Thanks again!

  2. franklparker

    Sha’Tara the cynic rides again! Of course, you are absolutely right. But what is the alternative? So long as the world contains more than one person our options are constrained by the presence of the others. I know you favour co-operation, as do I, but even that demands some loss of personal freedom.

    1. Sha'Tara Post author

      Thanks for your comment, Frank. With the little I know of philosophy, most of mine being home-grown (why I usually spell it “flossophy” as in mind flossing) I would say that life can be a process of gaining personal freedom, rather than a realization of loss of same. For example, we begin as a child which basically means no personal freedom at all, and we grow up through family discipline (the lucky ones!) then peer pressure, then more official system expectations and oppression. Through all this we can consider our “freedom” options, and make choices. The more personal freedom we choose, the more difficult will those choices be. For me, personal freedom means that what I am thinking, saying and involved in, is to some expanding extent, contributing to what I feel is personal freedom for me. Living in cooperation with some parts of society may be constraining, but if I make that my choice of lifestyle, i.e., I choose cooperative interaction (which I do at least locally) then it is my choice that provides me with my own sense if personal freedom. From a “servanthood” perspective (definitely not a popular concept these days) taken on by choice as a method of self-discipline, personal freedom is achieved by doing that which a “normal” person would consider below their dignity, or an interference in their expected enjoyment of life. In ways often never tested, a slave can enjoy more personal freedom than the richest or most powerful of individuals. There is much power in genuine humility, one of the few virtues I consider worth expressing, as long as one knows(!) the difference between serving from the will rather than force or obsequiousness and servility. Our will determines how we play the role.

  3. Lisa R. Palmer

    Sigh… yes. Right again. It’s exhausting, this truth. And the circular logic of it all. Chasing our tails endlessly, snapping only when an’Other crosses our endless, pointless, furrowed path…

    Off to work soon, to do my best Ignorant performance…

    1. Sha'Tara Post author

      Thanks for commenting, Lisa. If time permits, you may want to read my response to Frank Parker’s comment – you may find something there that says our labour doesn’t have to be from ignorance. There are alternatives we can explore…

  4. A writer from the East

    Very interesting post on ignorance and freedom… am afraid that in many cultures freedom is curbed by purposedly staying or keeping populations ignorant… great insight as usual!

  5. Rosaliene Bacchus

    Sha’Tara, as always, you’re an OMI at getting to the core of our alternative existence. Those of us who are awake to our reality must keep on nudging and shaking the sleep walkers around us.

  6. Phil Huston

    There is always that trade-off. Perceived security for a “freedom” token. Piece by piece “freedom” is eroded until the only place to be totally free is inside your own head. And I’m sure they’re working on that one.

    1. Sha'Tara Post author

      Missed that comment in the turmoil… Yes, “they” are working on total control. They’ve got the psych-ia-tricks inventing new mind-disorders for the drug-vaccine operatives by the minute.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.